Why metered broadband won’t last
When Verizon’s chief technology officer, Dick Lynch, recently predicted an end to flat-rate broadband, many in the industry saw it as a late entry into the general consensus. After all, the combination of runaway consumer bandwidth demand and meager service provider revenue growth is unsustainable, right?
Industry News
Blogs
Briefing Room
advertisement
“The concept of a flat-rated infinitely expanding service for everyone just won’t work,” Lynch told the audience at the Fiber-to-the-Home Conference.
Not everyone agrees.
“I think ultimately we’ll end up with a simple flat rate,” said Craig Labovitz, chief scientist for Arbor Networks, which sells network management systems. “The question is over what time scale.”
“Generally stuff starts out flat-rate, and it’s very expensive for a select few,” Labovitz said, citing the telegraph and the telephone as examples. “Then as it becomes more ubiquitous, it becomes metered as you try to relax capacity…and you try to dis-incentivize people from using your capacity. And then it ends up being flat-rate again as ultimately there’s a strong economic [force toward] consumers preferring simplicity as a key metric.”
Though the economic concepts he referred to aren’t new, Labovitz cited an academic paper written in 2007 by David Levinson and Andrew Odlyzko, professors at the University of Minnesota widely respected for their authority on Internet economics.
In that paper, Levinson and Odlyzko argued that metered prices can potentially pose the threat of under-consumption, even among users who don’t pose a burden to the network. They cite historic surges in usage that resulted from flat-rate pricing for Internet service in 1996 and mobile telephony in 1998. (Both were instigated by AT&T, incidentally.) They posit that bundled services are even easier to offer at a flat rate because high consumption of one service may be balanced out by less consumption of another. And they maintain that calculating metered charges comes with its own cost – for providers and consumers alike.
“The cost of collecting charges on each transaction, both in real terms for the operator and the user and in dissuading total demand by increasing marginal costs…makes [metering] too expensive,” the authors wrote, adding that metering does make sense in some cases, “When the aim is less to collect revenues and more to discourage usage.”
It’s hard to reconcile Verizon’s views about the untenable ratio of network costs to user demand with comments made by the same company at the same event just two years earlier. At the 2007 FTTH Conference, Terry Denson, vice president of FiOS TV content strategy and acquisition, boasted that Verizon would be able to offer 100-Mb/s services long before the market would find ways to use that much bandwidth. “I don't think customer behavior is going to get there for several years,” Denson said then.
If history is any guide, metering broadband would push customer demand for 100-Mb/s services even further away.
Want to use this article? Click here for options!
© 2010 Penton Media Inc.
advertisement
Learning Library
Webcasts
Trends in Customer Activation
Join us Thursday, February 25 for a look at emerging trends and technologies for more efficient, effective activation of customer accounts and services.
- Connected Business Models Series: The Innovation Engine
- Connected Business Models Series: The New Solution - sponsored by Motorola
- No Spectrum, No Problem: Learn the Potential of WiMAX on the Unlicensed Bands – sponsored by Alvarion
- Inside Telecom LIVE, Best Practices in IMS and NGN Deployment – sponsored by EXFO
White Papers
IPv6 Visibility and Protection: Best Practices for Managing and Securing IPv6 Traffic
Network operators need the same management and security capabilities for their IPv6 traffic that they are accustomed to today for their IPv4 traffic. Download this white paper to learn more...
Featured Content
Special Report: Making Quality King
Read how changing technology and changing requirements have made it essential for providers to monitor, test, manage and measure the Quality of Experience of their subscribers. DOWNLOAD NOW
of interest
The Latest
News
From the Blog
Briefingroom
Join the Discussion
Resources
Get more out of Connected Planet by visiting our related resources below:
Connected Planet highlights the next generation of service providers, as well as how their customers use services in new ways.
Subscribe Now






