Minnesota scraps multicity muni fiber plans
Industry News
Blogs
Briefing Room
advertisement
But after years of discussion, a fundamental change in the proposed model may have been a hard sell to city councilors. And critics of the project, including incumbent providers, still pointed to Utah’s troubled projects as cautionary tales.
“For over two years, the [Iron Range fiber project leaders] were using [Utah’s networks] as the business model, going to [Iron Range] cities and saying, ‘This is what we should do,’” said Gary Cerkvenik, a consultant with the Costin Group who helped Qwest Communications oppose the project. “Only this year did Gary Fields say, ‘I found a new business model, and his name is Timothy Nulty.’”
According to Cerkvenik, Hibbing city council members (who were unavailable to comment for this story) may also have been put off by the lack of specifics on the latest version of the project’s model. When asked by Telephony for a copy (or a detailed summary) of the proposal made to Hibbing, Fields said, “I don’t know that there’s a good accurate description of it. There’s not a lot of detail. Part of the problem is that the next step in providing more detail is to get more community commitments and then frame it a little more precisely. But it doesn’t look like that’s going to happen.”
Still, some of the project’s supporters blame incumbents, including Qwest, for the project’s demise.
“I believe it failed because incumbents were successful in sowing the seeds of doubt in the council’s mind in terms of the ultimate feasibility of the project,” said Brian Redshaw, Hibbing’s city administrator. “Obviously it was more than just the $15,000.”
Want to use this article? Click here for options!
© 2010 Penton Media Inc.
advertisement
Learning Library
Webcasts
Trends in Customer Activation
Join us for a look at emerging trends and technologies for more efficient, effective activation of customer accounts and services.
- Connected Business Models Series: The Innovation Engine
- Connected Business Models Series: The New Solution - sponsored by Motorola
- No Spectrum, No Problem: Learn the Potential of WiMAX on the Unlicensed Bands – sponsored by Alvarion
- Inside Telecom LIVE, Best Practices in IMS and NGN Deployment – sponsored by EXFO
White Papers
Going Beyond an Application Store
This whitepaper challenges the wireless industry to think beyond apps...
- How High-Tech Device Manufacturers Are Using Embedded Software to Grow Revenue
- Telecommunications Equipment Providers: Enhancing Customer Satisfaction, and Revenues, with Embedded Software
- IDC White Paper—Software Licensing & Entitlement Management: The Next Generation
- IPv6 Visibility and Protection: Best Practices for Managing and Securing IPv6 Traffic
Featured Content
Making the Most of Wireless Broadband
In this Connected Planet Tech Center, sponsored by Motorola, learn more about fixed wireless technology, investigate the solutions it can support... LEARN MORE
of interest
The Latest
News
From the Blog
Briefingroom
Join the Discussion
Resources
Get more out of Connected Planet by visiting our related resources below:
Connected Planet highlights the next generation of service providers, as well as how their customers use services in new ways.
Subscribe Now



